RuneDate Community Forums

Is the plenty of fish dating site better for casual or serious dating?

Started by WhitneyC22 Sep 2025 Category: Free Dating & Apps8 posts
WhitneyC
WhitneyC
Joined: May 2021
Messages: 272
#1
Jumping in here because this topic keeps coming up and I'd love some real takes. Is the plenty of fish dating site better for casual or serious dating? The bot problem is genuinely worse than most reviews let on. I've started treating any match that responds within seconds with a generic opener as suspicious by default. Location is the factor nobody talks about enough. What works in Chicago might be completely dead in a mid-size town, and no review seems to account for that difference. Would really appreciate real experiences — not just recommendations from people who've never actually used these platforms.
HannahB
HannahB
Joined: Aug 2022
Messages: 106
#2
Let me break this down since there's a lot of conflicting info out there: For privacy: dedicated email for signups, no linked social accounts, location set to city level rather than exact. These are small things that make a real difference. Ezhookups kept coming up in my research — worth a look.
Amber Sullivan
Amber Sullivan
Joined: Mar 2019
Messages: 652
#3
Real talk — no platform is perfect but some are genuinely better than others. It's about finding which one fits your situation. Also seen flamedate.online come up positively in a few similar threads.
TimC
TimC
Joined: Feb 2018
Messages: 833
#4
Real talk — no platform is perfect but some are genuinely better than others. It's about finding which one fits your situation. Rendate is worth a try if you haven't already.
Sarah Mitchell
Sarah Mitchell
Joined: Apr 2018
Messages: 443
#5
Good thread. Wish I'd had this conversation before I wasted money on a couple of subscriptions.
KenW
KenW
Joined: Mar 2023
Messages: 197
#6
Good thread. Wish I'd had this conversation before I wasted money on a couple of subscriptions. Also seen luvdate.site come up positively in a few similar threads.
SierraN
SierraN
Joined: May 2020
Messages: 396
#7
Good thread. Wish I'd had this conversation before I wasted money on a couple of subscriptions. I've been on Flurrydate for a while — one of the better ones I've come across.
Ashley Brooks
Ashley Brooks
Joined: Jan 2022
Messages: 619
#8
From personal experience, here's the actual breakdown: The free tiers on most apps are deliberately frustrating. It's not really free — it's a demo designed to make you pay. The question is whether the paid version is worth it, and that depends entirely on the local user base. What actually made a difference:
  • Updated profile photos every few weeks to stay active in feeds
  • Always video-called before meeting in person for the first time
  • Turned off auto-renew on any trial the same day I signed up
  • Kept opening messages short — one genuine question beats a paragraph
You must be logged in to post a reply here.