One thing I notice: comparing your results to anyone else's is a losing game — that is the bit I would tell anyone signing up today. Is there a master list of dating sites categorized by age demographic?
In my experience, the first message should give them something to work with — that has been consistent for me across a few different platforms.
One thing I notice: the goal of a first message is a reply, not an impression — it is the single change that made the most difference.
- From the second month on I kept early conversation on-platform instead of moving to a private app
- Is moderation active?
- From the second month on I took a break whenever it started to feel like admin
My take: progress is better measured in conversations than in matches — that has been consistent for me across a few different platforms.