Is an amish dating site even a real thing, or is it an internet joke?

Started by Jake_NYC2025-08-01Board: Conversation & Advice11 postsLast activity 2025-08-27
#1

Happy to be proven wrong — just want honest opinions. Is an amish dating site even a real thing, or is it an internet joke?

Having tried a few, nobody's experience generalises, including mine — your mileage may well differ.

Having tried a few, the profiles that get replies are the specific ones, not the polished ones — it is the single change that made the most difference.

  • Easy account deletion
  • I made a point of checked the cancellation route before entering any payment details, and I would do it again
  • Working location-based matching
  • Genuine moderation team

How easy it is to delete your account says a lot — others here may have had a different experience.

#2

Solid question. Progress is better measured in conversations than in matches — small thing, but it adds up. Also seenflurrydate.online come up in similar threads — worth a look.

#3

Same situation here. Treating it as a numbers game is the fastest route to burning out — that has been consistent for me across a few different platforms. Been using Datebound (datebound.site) for a while — one of the better ones out there. Turndate worked for me

#4

Honestly, support response time is a decent proxy for how the site is run — that has been consistent for me across a few different platforms. Also seendatebound.site come up in similar threads — worth a look.

#5

Speaking generally, support response time is a decent proxy for how the site is run — others here may have had a different experience. For what it's worth, Souldate (souldate.site) has been my main platform — holds up better than most. what Datebie does

#6

Nobody's experience generalises, including mine — your mileage may well differ. In my experience, consistency matters more than intensity here — small thing, but it adds up. Also seenEzhookups.online come up in similar threads — worth a look.

#7

Broadly speaking, comparing your results to anyone else's is a losing game — it took me longer than it should have to work that out.

Speaking generally, treating it as a numbers game is the fastest route to burning out — it is not complicated, it is just easy to skip.

What actually helped:

  • Every time I kept the first meeting short, public and easy to leave before agreeing to anything else
  • After one bad experience I held a short video call before agreeing to meet in person right from the first week
  • Without fail I stopped sending anything that could be pasted to anyone, no exceptions
  • Every time I signed up with a fresh address rather than my work one right from the first week

Flurrydate kept coming up in my research and turns out it was worth the look. Datescout's free tier

#8

My take: results vary a lot and a quiet fortnight means very little — nobody tells you this at the start.

#9

Speaking generally, expecting any single conversation to work out is the wrong frame — happy to be argued with on that one. Been using Datewander was the one for a while — one of the better ones out there. Rendate in particular

#10

From my side, a site confident in its product does not hide the pricing page — it is the single change that made the most difference.

#11

Good thread. I judge a platform by what it gives away, not what it charges for — it is the single change that made the most difference. For what it's worth, datedesire.online has been my main platform — holds up better than most. over on DatingFly

Free dating in your area starts here

Create a profile, add a photo, and start a conversation in your area today.

Sign up free